The CFO's Guide to AE Sales Comp: How to Design a Motivating Plan
The Goal:
Account Executives (AEs) are the engines of revenue growth. But a misaligned comp plan can seize the engine. Here is the financial framework for designing a plan that drives bookings without destroying your Cost of Sales.
This is Part 1 of our "Plan Design Series."
Designing an AE compensation plan is one of the highest-stakes financial decisions a company can make.
Get it right, and you create a high-performance sales engine that aligns everyone and fuels growth. Get it wrong, and you incentivize bad behavior, high turnover, or "empty calorie" revenue.
As a finance leader, you can't just "trust" a sales leader's gut feeling. You need a data-driven model.
Here is the 4-step framework for designing a financially sound AE plan.
Step 1: Benchmarking OTE & Pay Mix
Your first step isn't math; it's the market. What is the price of talent?
2026 Benchmarks (Mid-Market SaaS):
- SMB AE: $110k - $150k OTE
- Mid-Market AE: $160k - $230k OTE
- Enterprise AE: $260k - $360k+ OTE
The Pay Mix:
For a pure "hunter" role like an AE, the industry standard is 50/50.
- 50% Base Salary (Guaranteed security)
- 50% Variable Commission (At-risk incentive)
Why not 60/40? It reduces hunger. Why not 40/60? It creates too much anxiety, leading to turnover. Stick to 50/50 unless you have a very specific reason to deviate.
Step 2: The "Magic Number" (Quota-to-OTE Ratio)
This is the single most critical, and most misunderstood, part of comp design.
A rep's quota is not just a goal. It's a financial ratio.
To ensure your unit economics work, the Quota-to-OTE ratio must be 4x to 6x.
- $150k OTE x 5 = $750k Annual Quota.
The CFO Rule:
- Below 4x: Your Cost of Sales is too high (>25%). You are overpaying for revenue.
- Above 6x: The quota is likely unattainable. Reps will view it as "fantasy math" and disengage.
Step 3: Calculate the Commission Rate
Once you have your Variable Comp (Step 1) and your Quota (Step 2), the commission rate calculates itself.
Formula: (Variable Pay) / (Quota) = Base Commission Rate
Example: $75,000 / $750,000 = 10% Flat Rate
This is the "Aha!" moment. You don't pick a rate; you solve for it.
Step 4: Flat Rate vs. Accelerators
A flat 10% is simple. But to drive "over-performance," you need Accelerators.
Standard SaaS Accelerator Model:
- 0-100% of Quota: 10% (Base Rate)
- 100-125% of Quota: 12% (1.2x Multiplier)
- 125%+ of Quota: 15% (1.5x Multiplier)
Warning: Always model the "Worst Case" scenario. If a rep hits 300% of quota due to a lucky "bluebird" deal, can you afford the payout? If not, consider a "windfall clause" in your plan.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Should we pay on Bookings or Cash?
For AEs, Bookings is standard. You want them focused on closing the deal, not chasing invoices. However, you must pair this with a Clawback Policy (e.g., 90-day retention) to protect the company from bad deals.
Should we cap commissions?
Never cap commissions. Capping upside sends the message: "Stop selling." If you are worried about runaway costs, use "Decelerators" on ultra-high attainment or a windfall review clause, but never a hard cap.
What about multi-year deals?
Incentivize them! A common structure is to pay the full commission rate on Year 1 ACV, and a reduced rate (e.g., 2-5%) on TCV (Total Contract Value) for years 2 and 3.
Related Reading
Build Your AE Plan in 5 Minutes
Don't rely on gut feel. Use our free tool to benchmark OTEs, calculate your Quota-to-OTE ratio, and model accelerator impacts instantly.
Design Your AE Plan Now →Stay in the Loop
Get updates on new features, resources, and insights on sales compensation.
